Managed IT 3 min read

Our IT guy quit. Hire another one or hire a consultant?

The first week matters more than the hiring decision. Secure what he knew, then decide who should own IT.

The question

We are 15 people in Cleveland and our IT guy just quit. Do we hire another one or hand it to a consultant?

The company is a small professional-services firm. He had been the only person who touched IT for years, and nobody else knows where anything lives.

What we told them

Before you decide who to hire, deal with what walked out the door. A one-person IT department keeps the company's keys in his head: the Microsoft 365 admin login, the domain registrar, the firewall, the backup console, the Wi-Fi controller, the vendor accounts. This week, find out who owns each of those, make sure at least two people in the company can reach them, and rotate every password he held. This is not about distrust. It is what you would do if he had been hit by a bus, and the answer is the same whether he left on good terms or not.

Then the real question. At 15 people, a single full-time hire usually means one generalist covering helpdesk, security, backups, and every vendor. That person cannot take a vacation without leaving you uncovered, cannot be an expert in everything, and when they leave you are back here. That is how you got here.

Our opinion: at your size, hand it to a consultant or a managed provider and keep one person inside the company as the decision-maker. Often that is the office manager. They do not fix anything. They approve requests, own the vendor relationship, and know who to call. You get a team behind the one seat, documented systems, and security monitored by people whose job it is.

A second hire can still be right. If you have constant on-site hardware work, or the business runs on equipment that needs someone in the building every day, in-house starts to earn its place. For an office running on Microsoft 365, laptops, and a handful of line-of-business apps, it rarely does.

Whoever you choose, ask for the same thing on day one: a written inventory of every system, who administers it, and where the credentials are kept. If a provider cannot hand you that in the first few weeks, keep looking.

The takeaway

Recover the keys first, then decide who should hold them. At 15 people, a team behind one seat beats a single hire who becomes the next single point of failure.

Got a question like this one?

Send it over — 20 minutes, no pitch, a straight answer either way.