Cybersecurity 3 min read

How to answer a cyber insurance application without guessing

A yes you cannot back up is the dangerous answer. Treat the application as a checklist and go get the evidence.

The question

Our broker says the cyber insurance renewal application now asks about MFA, backups and a few other things. Our IT person is part-time and I don't want to guess. How do we answer these without getting it wrong?

A 25-person services firm renewing a policy it has carried for three years, with a part-time IT contractor, Microsoft 365 and a mix of laptops.

What we told them

Don't answer from memory, and don't let anyone answer for you from memory either. The questions are on the form because claims hinge on them. A “yes” you cannot back up is the dangerous answer: if you ever claim, the insurer checks, and a control you said you had and did not is the kind of thing that turns a claim into a dispute. A “no” costs you a higher premium or an exclusion, which is cheaper than finding out after an incident that you were never covered the way you thought.

So treat the application as a checklist, and for each line go find the evidence, not the opinion. MFA: the policy that enforces it on email, remote access and every administrator account, with the list of exceptions (the right number is zero). Backups: where the copies live, whether they are offline or immutable, and the date of the last restore test, not the last successful backup. Endpoint detection and response: the console showing every computer and server covered, and who watches the alerts. Patching: the report showing how long critical updates take to land. The response plan: the written document, with names and phone numbers. The ten controls insurers commonly ask about are on one printable page on our site, with a yes, no or not sure next to each.

Anything you cannot prove goes on a fix list before you sign, not after. Most items are days of work: enforcing MFA in Microsoft 365, turning on a backup and restoring from it once, deploying EDR to a couple of dozen machines. Some take longer, and for those the honest answer on the form is the plan with a date, which brokers see all the time. What they do not forgive is the confident yes that was not true.

If you would rather have it checked than check it yourself, that is what a cyber insurance readiness assessment is: someone goes through the ten controls in your environment, writes down what is in place with the evidence, and hands you the fix list and the proof you can show your broker. Ours is our Discovery / scoping audit aimed at the application, a fixed fee from $2,500, credited to the engagement if you do the fixes with us.

Our opinion: the application is not a quiz. It is the list of things the insurer will check on the worst day you have. Answer with proof, fix what you cannot prove, and your renewal turns into the cheapest security audit you will ever get.

The takeaway

Never answer the application from memory. For each control, find the evidence: the MFA policy, the restore test date, the EDR console. Anything you cannot prove goes on the fix list before you sign. A guessed yes is the answer that comes back on claim day.

Got a question like this one?

Send it over — 20 minutes, no pitch, a straight answer either way.